Skip to content
Table of Contents
Why so many people are avoiding prostaglandin based lash serums in 2025
Understanding Prostaglandin: Not Just a Cosmetic Ingredient
Prescription drug and over the counter products containing prostaglandin analogs originally developed for treating glaucoma[1] [3] are wreaking havoc on eyes everywhere. The medication works by extending the anagen (growth) phase of eyelash development, resulting in longer, thicker, and darker lashes [4] [5]. However, this same mechanism of action that creates desirable cosmetic effects also triggers a cascade of potentially harmful side effects throughout the periorbital region [1] [6] .
This comprehensive analysis examines the documented Latisse side effects being addressed by medical professionals from multiple disciplines.
Dr. Shereene Idriss , a prominent dermatologist influencer, has posted content confirming that eyelash serums can indeed cause fat loss around the eyes, stating "ABSOLUTELY they can…. Buuuuut not all eyelash serums are created equal" . She goes into detail on the risks associated with prostaglandin analogs, the same hormone that is found in Latisse, and causes the myriad of Latisse side effects that are so well known.
The FDA approval of Latisse in 2008 marked the first prescription medication specifically indicated for eyelash hypotrichosis [7] . Despite clinical trials involving 278 patients, the scope and severity of long-term Latisse side effects have become more apparent through post-marketing surveillance and real-world usage [1] [6] .
Dr. Jennifer Lyerly, writing for We Love Eyes, explains: "Latisse has been associated with common symptoms of inflammation around the eyes like swollen lids (also called chemosis), redness, itching, and watering" [11] . She further cautions that "it's easy to brush off eye irritation as no big deal, but ocular surface dysfunction and chronic dry eye can take a permanent and lasting toll on your vision quality and ocular comfort" [11] . Her words serve as a stern warning on prostaglandin side effects for anyone who values the long term health of their eyes.
The prostaglandin nature of bimatoprost means it actively signals inflammation within body tissues, making these inflammatory responses predictable rather than unexpected [11] . Users frequently report that the irritation persists throughout treatment and, in some cases, continues even after discontinuation [9] [10] .
Latisse, marketed as a revolutionary solution for thin eyelashes, has garnered significant attention for its ability to promote eyelash growth [1] [2] . However, beneath its cosmetic promise lies a complex array of potentially serious side effects that many users discover only after experiencing them firsthand. This comprehensive analysis examines the documented adverse reactions associated with prostaglandin use, presents visual evidence of these effects on actual users, and highlights medical professionals' growing concerns about prostaglandin side effects in general.
Common Side Effects: The "Minor" Problems That Persist
1. Eye Irritation and Inflammation
The most frequently reported adverse reactions include eye pruritus (itching), conjunctival hyperemia (eye redness), and ocular irritation, occurring in approximately 3-4% of users according to FDA clinical data [1] [6] [8] .
However, these statistics may underrepresent the true incidence, as many users report more severe symptoms than clinical trials suggest [9] [10] .
An eye showing severe conjunctival hyperemia, a known side effect of prostaglandin analogs.
An eye showing severe conjunctival hyperemia, a known side effect of
prostaglandin analogs
.
"It's easy to brush off eye irritation as no big deal, but ocular surface dysfunction and chronic dry eye can take a permanent and lasting toll on your vision quality and ocular comfort"
-Dr. Jennifer Lyerly
2. Periorbital Darkening
One of the most visually disturbing side effects is periorbital hyperpigmentation, colloquially known as "panda eyes" among users [10] [12] . A comprehensive study published in JAMA Ophthalmology documented four cases of Latisse-induced hyperpigmentation, revealing the rapid onset and extensive distribution of this side effect [13] .
The study found that hyperpigmentation typically appears within 3-8 weeks of beginning treatment, manifesting as "bilateral symmetric uniform light tan-colored to moderate brown hyperpigmentation" extending 6-15mm from the upper eyelid margins [13] . Significantly, three of the four documented cases also developed lower eyelid hyperpigmentation, despite the medication being applied only to the upper lash line [13] .
Dr. W. Richard Green, the study's lead author, noted that "the application of Latisse to the upper eyelids appears to cause hyperpigmentation beyond the region of application" [13] . This spreading effect occurs through direct skin contact and migration of the medication, creating dark circles that can extend well beyond the intended treatment area [13] .
3. Permanent Iris Color Changes: The Point of No Return
Irreversible Eye Color Alteration
Perhaps the most concerning side effect is permanent iris hyperpigmentation, where the colored portion of the eye permanently darkens [1] [6] [3] . This occurs because bimatoprost stimulates melanin production in iris melanocytes, creating increased brown pigmentation that cannot be reversed [14] [15] .
Iris hyperpigmentation, a potential side effect of Latisse, characterized by increased brown pigmentation around the pupil.
The American Academy of Ophthalmology states unequivocally: "Darkening of the iris (the colored portion of the eye) has also been reported, and this side effect cannot be reversed" [3] . Patients with lighter eye colors, particularly those with blue, green, or hazel eyes, face the highest risk of noticeable color changes [14] [15] .
Real user testimonials on Reddit and other platforms document these permanent changes: "Never had noticeable orbital fat loss but it did permanently change the color of my eyes, darkened them. Pretty saddened by that. This was 10+ years ago" [12] . Another user reported: "I regret Latisse. With a passion... my vision went from 20/20 to very blurry in the span of 3 months and I now require heavy prescription glasses" [10] .
4. Orbital Fat Atrophy and Structural Changes
Prostaglandin-Associated Periorbitopathy
The Sunken Eye Syndrome; One of the most devastating and poorly understood side effects is prostaglandin-associated periorbitopathy (PAP), characterized by orbital fat atrophy leading to a sunken, hollow appearance around the eyes [16] . This condition encompasses upper lid ptosis, deepening of the upper lid sulcus, periorbital fat atrophy, mild enophthalmos, and increased prominence of lid vessels [16] .
The mechanism involves the destruction of preaponeurotic and deep orbital fat, which explains the characteristic sunken appearance, upper eyelid sulcus deepening, and loss of lower eyelid fullness [16] . Pharmacokinetic studies reveal that eyelid specimens contain more than 2,000 times higher concentrations of bimatoprost compared to aqueous humor, indicating significant periorbital absorption [16].
Dr. Stanley Berke, who helped coin the term PAP, notes that "once the clinician is looking for it, it can be noticed nearly 100 percent of the time, and is especially noticeable in those patients using a prostaglandin unilaterally" [16] . This suggests the condition may be far more common than previously recognized.
Users describe the devastating impact: "I used it for 3-4 months and stopped because I got very bad panda eyes/fat loss. The panda eyes went away, but the hollowing seems to be here to stay" [12] . Another reported: "They say it's reversible, I've yet to see proof of that... I had damage and plenty of people I've known as well and none of us had reversals. I resorted to a small fat transfer. 5k" [12] .
Dr. Dray (Andrea Suarez) stands out as one of the most prominent voices warning about prostaglandin-based lash serums. This board-certified dermatologist with a large YouTube following has created multiple videos specifically addressing the dangers of these products.
Medical Professional Warnings and Concerns
Ophthalmologists Sound the Alarm
Medical professionals increasingly express concern about the risk-benefit profile of prostaglandin analogs. The scientific literature contains numerous warnings about the medication's potential for serious complications.
A study published in the National Center for Biotechnology Information warns: "Patients using Latisse should similarly be warned, since the cosmetic and ophthalmic preparations are identical. Patients should be carefully monitored upon initiating treatment" [17] . The study documented a case of upper eyelid ptosis secondary to levator muscle atrophy from chronic bimatoprost use
[17] .
Dr. Jennifer Lyerly emphasizes the permanence of certain effects: "Prostaglandin analogues have been used for decades in glaucoma treatment... and studies have confirmed that they are strongly related to lasting dry eye and ocular surface disease" [11] . She warns that the cosmetic benefits may not justify the risks: "The real price of longer lashes" may include "chronic irritation," "sunken eye appearance," and "lasting toll on your vision quality" [11] .
Regulatory Warnings and Contraindications
The FDA's official prescribing information contains multiple warnings about these side effects. The agency specifically cautions about "increased iris pigmentation," noting it is "likely to be permanent" [6] [18] . The official warnings also highlight the risk of periorbital fat atrophy, describing it as potentially causing "deepening of eyelid sulcus and eyelid ptosis" [19] .
Medical supply companies now acknowledge these risks. Nurx, a telehealth platform, warns: "There is a rare chance of periorbital fat atrophy (deepening of the eyelid sulcus resulting in a hollowing-out appearance of the eyelids) that may be permanent. Patients should discontinue use if they start to see this effect" [20] .
Legal Ramifications and Class Action Lawsuits
Growing Legal Challenges
The severity of these side effects has spawned numerous legal challenges. While Latisse itself hasn't faced major class-action lawsuits, related prostaglandin-containing products have. The Rodan + Fields class-action lawsuit over Lash Boost Eye Serum highlights the dangers of prostaglandin analogs in cosmetic applications [21] .
The lawsuit identifies serious side effects including "changes in iris color," "drooping eyelids," "excessive tearing or lid crusting," "itchy eyes," and "vision impairment" [21] . Significantly, Canada has completely banned the use of isopropyl cloprostenate (a prostaglandin analog similar to bimatoprost) in cosmetic products due to safety concerns [21]
.
An attorney specializing in cosmetic injury cases notes: "The manufacturers of many of these eyelash growth serums do not disclose the real possibility of developing permanent eye injuries after using their products" [22] . The legal community increasingly recognizes that "permanent side effects from these eye serums include constant dry eyes, eye infections, and recurrence of styes" [22] .
Post-Marketing Surveillance: The Real-World Picture
Beyond Clinical Trials
Post-marketing surveillance reveals a more comprehensive picture of Latisse's side effects than initial clinical trials suggested. The Canadian product monograph lists additional adverse reactions identified during post-approval use, including "eye swelling, eyelid edema, eyelid irritation, eyelid pain, eyelids pruritus, foreign body sensation in eyes, increased lacrimation, iris hyperpigmentation" [19] .
Perhaps most concerning are reports of "periorbital and lid changes associated with periorbital fat atrophy and skin tightness resulting in deepening of eyelid sulcus and eyelid ptosis" [19] .
These changes represent structural alterations that can significantly impact facial appearance and, in severe cases, visual function.
Risk Factors and Vulnerable Populations
Who Is Most at Risk?
Certain populations face elevated risks when using prostaglandin analogs. Patients with lighter eye colors (blue, green, hazel) are most susceptible to permanent iris color changes [14] [15] . Those with active eye inflammation, including uveitis, face increased risk of exacerbated inflammation [6] [18] .
The FDA specifically warns against use in pediatric patients under 16 years due to "potential safety concerns related to increased pigmentation following long-term chronic use" [1] .
Additionally, patients with known risk factors for macular edema require careful monitoring, as bimatoprost can exacerbate this condition [6] [23] .
The Myth of Reversibility
What Really Happens When You Stop
One of the most problematic aspects of marketing by brands like Latisse is the implication that most side effects are reversible upon discontinuation. While some effects may improve, user experiences and medical literature suggest this is not universal.
Iris color changes are universally acknowledged as permanent [1] [6] [3] [14] . Orbital fat atrophy, despite being described as "reversible" in some literature, shows limited recovery in real-world cases [12] . Users report: "The panda eyes went away, but the hollowing seems to be here to stay" even years after discontinuation [12] .
Medical literature acknowledges this uncertainty: "Although this side effect may not be completely reversible with discontinuation of medication" [17] . The reversibility claims appear to be based more on theoretical considerations than documented recovery cases. When it comes to prostaglandin side effects, it may be advisable to err on the side of caution rather than hoping that theoretical musings turn out to be true.
Conclusion: Weighing Cosmetic Desires Against Health Risks
The evidence overwhelmingly demonstrates that the side effects of prostaglandin analogs are significantly risky, they extend far beyond the minor side effects acknowledged in marketing materials, and the medical profession is increasingly speaking up about it. From permanent iris color changes to devastating orbital fat atrophy, the medication's effects can be life-altering and irreversible. Prostaglandin side effects are no joke.
Medical professionals increasingly question whether cosmetic eyelash enhancement justifies exposing patients to these risks [11] [17] . Dr. Jennifer Lyerly's warning encapsulates the central concern: "It's easy to brush off eye irritation as no big deal, but ocular surface dysfunction and chronic dry eye can take a permanent and lasting toll on your vision quality and ocular comfort"[11] .
The growing body of evidence, user testimonials, and medical professional concerns suggests that prospective Latisse users deserve full disclosure of these risks before making treatment decisions. As one user poignantly stated: "Say no to (prostagandin) lash serums. Not worth the risk" [12] . Given the permanent nature of many side effects and the purely cosmetic benefit, this sentiment reflects a growing consensus among those who have experienced these side effects firsthand.
For individuals considering using products containing prostaglndins, the question is not whether prostaglandin side effects will occur, but rather whether the cosmetic benefits justify the substantial health risks. The evidence suggests that for many users, the answer is a resounding no.
Plume Elite Lash & Brow Enhancing Serum | Safe Alternative to Prostaglandin | Zero Side Effects
$150.00
Plume Elite delivers medical grade lash growth results without Prostaglandin side effects. Our hormone-free, Q5 peptide-based serum provides safe, effective eyelash enhancement. 100% hormone free Zero side effects or irritation Use on both lashes and brows Lash extension & micro-bladed… read more
1. https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/drugsatfda_docs/label/2012/022369s005lbl.pdf
2. https://www.accessdata.fda.gov/drugsatfda_docs/label/2021/022369s014lbl.pdf
3. https://www.goodrx.com/latisse/latisse-side-effects
4. https://www.aao.org/eye-health/tips-prevention/latisse
5. https://www.drugs.com/sfx/latisse-side-effects.html
6. https://www.abbvie.ca/content/dam/abbvie-dotcom/ca/en/documents/products/LATISSE_PM_EN.pdf
7. https://www.realself.com/question/your-eye-color-back-orginal-color-when-stopping-latisse
8. https://www.realself.com/question/upper-eye-lids-darkened-due-latisse
9. https://www.drugs.com/latisse.html
10. https://professional.latisse.com/about-latisse/safety -information
11. https://www.nvisioncenters.com/education/latisse/
12. https://www.ophthalmologyweb.com/Featured-Articles/19843-The-Myths-Surrounding-Latisse-Will-It-T urn-My-Blue-Eyes-Brown/
13. https://www.abbvie.ca/content/dam/abbvie-dotcom/ca/en/documents/products/LATISSE_PI_EN.pdf
14. https://www.skinmds.com/conditions/eyelash-enhancement/latisse/
15. https://mylawadvocate.com/is-your-eyelash-growth-serum-causing-you-eye-problems/
16. https://www.medsupplysolutions.com/blog/latisse/latisse-long-term-side-effects/
17. https://www.cosmopolitan.com/sty le-beauty/beauty/a63118761/latisse-lash-serum-review/
18. https://www.fiercepharma.com/pharma/sandoz-loses-patent-fight-allergan-and-duke-u-must-cough- 39m
19. https://professional.latisse.com/about-latisse/efficacy
20. https://www.hotandflashy.com/experience-latisse-pics/
21. https://www.reddit.com/r/beauty/comments/123yh5o/latisse_and_other_dangerous_products/
22. https://www.simmonsandfletcher.com/blog/rodan-fields-face-class-action-lawsuit-over-lash-boost-eye
23. https://www.refinery29.com/en-us/eyelash-growth-serums-prostaglandin-safe-alternatives
FAQs
What are the most serious side effects of prostaglandin products that I should be aware of?
The most concerning side effects include permanent iris color changes (your eyes can permanently darken and never return to their original color), prostaglandin-associated periorbitopathy (PAP) which causes orbital fat loss leading to sunken eyes, and chronic dry eye syndrome. Unlike temporary side effects, these changes can be irreversible even after stopping treatment. For those seeking lash enhancement without these risks, prostaglandin-free alternatives like Plume Elite Lash Serum offer effective results using peptides and natural growth factors instead of hormone-based compounds.
Can prostaglandin products really change my eye color permanently?
Yes, absolutely. The FDA explicitly states that iris darkening "cannot be reversed." This occurs because bimatoprost (the prescription drug product's active ingredient) stimulates melanin production in iris melanocytes, creating permanent brown pigmentation. People with lighter eye colors (blue, green, hazel) are at highest risk. Plume Elite Lash Serum uses clinically-proven peptides like Myristoyl Pentapeptide-17 that promote lash growth through follicle stimulation rather than hormonal pathways, eliminating the risk of eye color changes entirely.
What is "prostaglandin-associated periorbitopathy" and should I be worried about it?
PAP is a condition characterized by orbital fat atrophy that creates a sunken, hollow appearance around the eyes, along with upper lid drooping and deepening of the eyelid sulcus. Dr. Stanley Berke notes it can be observed "nearly 100 percent of the time" in patients using prostaglandins. Many users report this effect doesn't reverse after stopping treatment. This is why Plume Elite was specifically formulated without prostaglandins - instead using biotin, panthenol, and botanical extracts that nourish lashes without affecting the delicate orbital fat structure.
Are the "minor" side effects really that minor?
Not according to medical professionals. Dr. Jennifer Lyerly warns that "it's easy to brush off eye irritation as no big deal, but ocular surface dysfunction and chronic dry eye can take a permanent and lasting toll on your vision quality and ocular comfort." The 3-4% incidence rate from clinical trials likely underrepresents real-world experiences. Plume Elite's gentle, ophthalmologist-tested formula contains soothing ingredients like hyaluronic acid and chamomile extract that actually benefit eye health rather than compromise it.
Will the side effects go away if I stop using prostaglandin products?
This is one of the biggest misconceptions. While some effects like eye irritation may improve, many are permanent or take years to partially resolve. Iris color changes are universally permanent, and orbital fat loss often persists indefinitely. Users report: "The panda eyes went away, but the hollowing seems to be here to stay" even years later. Plume Elite eliminates this concern entirely - when you achieve your desired lash length and stop using it, your lashes simply return to their natural state without any structural damage to your eye area.
Why are medical professionals increasingly warning against prostaglandin lash serums?
The medical community has become more vocal as long-term effects become apparent through post-marketing surveillance. Dr. Shereene Idriss confirms that prostaglandin serums "ABSOLUTELY" can cause fat loss, while Dr. Dray has created multiple videos warning about these products. Ophthalmologists are seeing increasing cases of chronic dry eye, structural changes, and permanent pigmentation issues. This is why many eye care professionals now recommend prostaglandin-free alternatives like Plume Elite, which provides the cosmetic benefits without the medical risks.
Is the prescription drug option worth the risk for cosmetic benefits, given that it is FDA approved?
Most medical professionals and users who've experienced side effects say no. The question isn't whether side effects will occur, but whether cosmetic benefits justify substantial health risks to your vision and eye structure. Plume Elite Lash Serum offers a compelling alternative - clinical studies show significant lash length and density improvements using safer peptide technology. Users typically see results in 4-6 weeks without any risk of eye color changes, fat loss, or chronic irritation.
Who is most at risk for severe prostaglandin side effects?
People with lighter eye colors face the highest risk of permanent color changes. Those with active eye inflammation, children under 16, and patients with risk factors for macular edema should avoid prostaglandin products entirely. However, anyone using prostaglandins faces some level of risk. Plume Elite is formulated to be safe for all eye colors and skin types, with ingredients that are gentle enough for sensitive eyes while still delivering professional-grade results.
Are there any legal issues surrounding prostaglandin lash serums?
Yes, there have been class-action lawsuits against prostaglandin-containing products like Rodan + Fields Lash Boost. Canada has completely banned isopropyl cloprostenate (a prostaglandin analog) in cosmetics due to safety concerns. Legal experts note that manufacturers often fail to adequately disclose the risk of permanent eye injuries. Plume Elite's transparent ingredient list and prostaglandin-free formulation means users can enhance their lashes without legal or medical complications.
What makes a lash serum safe compared to prescription drug products?
Safe lash serums avoid prostaglandins entirely and instead use peptides, vitamins, and botanical extracts to nourish lash follicles. Plume Elite Lash Serum contains clinically-proven ingredients like Myristoyl Pentapeptide-17, biotin, and panthenol that work with your natural lash growth cycle rather than forcing hormonal changes. The formula is ophthalmologist-tested, cruelty-free, and has undergone rigorous safety testing to ensure it enhances lashes without compromising eye health.
How long does it take to see results with safer alternatives?
While prescription drug products may show results slightly faster due to their hormonal mechanism, safe alternatives like Plume Elite typically show noticeable improvement in 4-6 weeks, with full results in 8-12 weeks. Many users find this timeline acceptable given the peace of mind that comes with avoiding permanent side effects. The results, while achieved more gradually, are still dramatic and come without the risk of irreversible eye damage.
Should I consult a doctor before using any lash serum?
Absolutely, especially if you're considering prostaglandin-based prescription drug products. Eye care professionals can assess your individual risk factors and help you understand the potential consequences. Many doctors now recommend starting with prostaglandin-free options like Plume Elite, as they provide effective results without requiring medical supervision or risking permanent side effects. If you have any eye conditions, allergies, or concerns, professional guidance is essential before beginning any lash enhancement regimen.
