Nancy M.
I like this pencil and really appreciate the refills. I wish the leads lasted a bit longer, though. It’s great that you get 2 in the refill pack. I tried a lighter color, Golden Silk, this time and I think I will go back to Ashy Daybreak for the pencil. It takes a bit of pressure to have the color show up in my brows. But, combined with Ashy Daybreak, it adds some softness.
Janis M.
I have basically no eyebrows and I love the way this makes my eyebrows that I apply, look real. I get compliments all the time.
Claire B.
Been using this for several years, a fav/go to product that works well with brow gel. Only downside was the price increase when they went from a pack of three to only two a while back. One refill lasts about a month, so a pack is good for approximately two months.
Claire B.
Best I’ve found that is twist advance/doesn’t need to be sharpened. It applies smoothly, though care is necessary not to expose too much of the tip or apply too much pressure to prevent a piece breaking off. Have used for several years in combination with brow gel. Willing to pay the price (sales whenever possible), having switched entirely to clean cosmetics.
Elizabeth S.
Although I really like this product, the pencil is very fragile and snaps easily. I have also found that some refills seem to have broken product even before using.
Claire B.
Best product I’ve found
Brenda D.
Best product out there for aging eyebrows that are becoming sparse.
Arianne S.
I love this product. It’s a lifesaver!!
Debra R.
I like how the brow pencil glides on and have purchased refills twice however not sure the cost balances with the pencil not lasting as long as others.
Gina R.
These used to be great, now they don't retract or hold properly so they break all the time and a lot of product gets wasted. I go through them much too fast as a result. I was on a subscription for them but I unfortunately have to cancel it. I love Plume, especially the lash serum, but I can't keep using this pencil.
Kara G.
Love the product and have bought it a few times thru other distributors, but it runs out very, very quickly. There is barely any liner in the refills. I will not be purchasing again because I cannot justify purchasing it every few weeks.
Janis M.
I've been using the Ashy DayBreak eyebrow pencil for over a year now. I don't have ANY eyebrows to speak of, and you really can't tell with Plume's pencil! ALSO, I have chemical sensitivities which make me itch with most other brands. This one's free of all the toxic ingredients.
Frances D.
These are all photos of Day 1 brows to compare colour (not hair growth). As a natural dark blonde, my gut instinct was to go with Ashy Daybreak. Then I noticed that a lot of people with hair darker than mine would use Ashy Daybreak for a subtler look, so I was curious to try and recreate that look for myself. I got a Golden Silk pencil with some Ashy Daybreak refills. The Golden Silk looked “green” to me online, but I realized later that, as someone with lots of red pigment in their skin, the green undertones in Golden Silk help to keep it looking “cool” on my skin (other pencils end up looking reddish/orange on me). Honestly, I think the differences between the two colours are subtle—I really only notice them during application: in the yellow bathroom lighting, Golden Silk is so light that it’s hard to see while I put it on, it almost blends into my skin. I only notice a difference when step back. The Ashy Daybreak is more obvious during application, it’s significantly darker. I like to lightly “sketch” on my eyebrows, if I pushed down harder, then the Ashy Daybreak may become overwhelming. I like both colours, I think I still prefer Ashy Daybreak but I think Golden Silk is more forgiving during application, kind of like the difference between a 6H and 2B pencil, for the artists out there! Overall, the Ashy Daybreak seems more brown-pigmented.
S
I have been using this product for over two years. Overall I have been happy with it and don't use any other brow product aince I started with plume. However, I use it correctly and the recommended way, but there are some packages recently that seem to last less than a week. I haven't used it any more/differently than usual. Pretty disappointed there. Overall I will keep using it. Really appreciate that it is a vegan product since that is important to me.
Frances D.
I use the ashy daybreak eyebrow defines. It’s a perfect colour for me, applies very smoothly. Also the eyelash enhancer appears to work, my lashes appear thicker generally, and I think they are longer, I’m older. The lash growth slowed down and lashes were not growing noticeably. It’s a lovely product.
Thank you.
R C.
I've been using Ashy daybreak for over a year and have purchased this for my sisters and mother I love it that much. I purchase the refills and have had some bad luck with a few packs where I feel like the refill lasts a week or minimal uses. I know the pencil is soft but this felt like a defect. I decided to purchase the pomade this time along with refills to ensure I have back up in the cartridge fails. I will email customer service if I have this trouble with my current supply.
Janis M.
I have no eyebrows of my own, so I have been using eyebrow pencils forever! I am limited in what I can use, because I am allergic to chemicals. When I find one I'm not allergic to, it usually is too hard, or too soft, or too dark. I LOVE THE ASHY DAYBREAK pencil from Plume! It goes on smoothly, doesn't cause a rash, and looks soooo natural. Thanks PLUME!
Stephanie K.
I love this product. It is easy to apply, goes on very smoothly and looks great. Of the few non toxic brow pencils that I have tried, this one is by far the best. I love the fact that I don't have to try to sharpen it, but it's always there for me to use. I have highly recommended it to friends and will continue to buy it.
Virginia B.
Love this product!
Shanon
So happy to have a value pack.
Shanon
Best brow pencil out there! Looks natural and easy to apply.
Elizabeth E.
Nice product. Good colour match.
Leah H.
Love how natural the color looks and the ease of application. It stays all day too.
erika B.
a staple in my beauty routine. my eyebrows look full and natural with this great product!
Kathryn H.
Easy to use and makes me feel great
!
Michelle B.
I love that this product is refillable so less plastic waste being put in landfills! I also enjoy that it is a clean product! Great value for the money!
Alyssa K.
My perfect brow pencil. It's a soft, matte crayon texture that blends easily and the color is very natural (I use the chestnut). I really appreciate they made it refillable - less waste and more affordable over time. There are no harsh ingredients, no irritation. Love it, have been using at least a year and don't plan to ever shop for a brow pencil again.
Sarah O.
It glides on so smooth with a precise tip. It doesn't pull out my weak eyebrow hairs so my brows are looking fuller. And I love that I can use a refill instead of buying another unit. I will be buying this from now on.
erika B.
My favorite eyebrow pencil. So easy to work with and love the refills!
Stephanie K.
love this eyebrow pencil. It goes on very smoothly and looks good. I would love the refills to last a bit longer but i will continue to repeatedly purchase as I have not found any other to be as good.
Stephanie K.
I love this eyebrow pencil. It goes on very smoothly and looks good. I would love the refills to last a bit longer but i will continue to repeatedly purchase as I have not found any other to be as good.
Elizabeth S.
Love this eyebrow pencil! It stays put all day and doesn’t irritate my skin like other pencils I’ve tried. Great product!
Gina H.
I've been using Plume Eyebrow Pencils for a couple of years and I love the refill packs. Chocolate Decadence is my perfect shade, the formula is easy to apply and stays on all day without smudging.
Elizabeth S.
This is the first eyebrow pencil I’ve used in some time that does not irritate my skin. It goes on easily and stays on all day. I appreciate that I can refill the liner- a great feature!
Leah M.
Perfect shade and doesn't look to heavy!
Melissa S.
I love how it is the perfect color and looks so natural with my skin and matches my hair!
Beth S.
Love! Best brow pencil ever.
Jennifer D.
I love this eyebrow pencil so much! It’s the perfect shade and goes on so smoothly and perfectly. I love that it has a refill pack that I can keep re-ordering!
Elizabeth E.
Love how easily this product is to use and the results are beautiful
Jennifer D.
Love this so much it goes on so nice and natural. Just the right shade too
Lindsay C.
Been using this brow pencil for over a year. The best color, ingredients and staying power brow pencil on the organic clean beauty market, hands down! And I've tried a ton since switching to non-toxic beauty products back in 2010. Thank you Plume!
Felicia L.
Great product but the applicator isn’t the best. Brow pencil breaks super easily. Plume said they are trying to fix this issue. I’ve just been using refills on its own without placing in applicator.
Leah B.
The only brow pencil goes on like a dream, that stays on all day, and truly no red cast to this brown. THE BEST EVER!
Sarah P.
Great Product for a redhead!
Tracy T.
I love this eyebrow pencil - it only takes little strokes to create great brows!
Gina H.
I love my Plume eyebrow pencil in Chocolate Decadence so I bought my stepmom one in Autumn Sunset. She loves it! She said it is the best shade ever. I just ordered the refill for her.
Stephanie K.
This is an excellet product. I love the fact that it is not a pencil that needs sharpened and I also love that it is free of harmful chemicals. I just wish that the refill lasted longer. I find that I am replacing it frequently, as it runs out so quickly and I do not use a lot at a time.
Maria H.
I love the low waste intent behind this product and the actual product itself. It doesn’t come out shiny, I would say use a light hand to get the best results. It also helps your eyebrows grow, which is pretty cool, so you need to use it less and less. I loved it so much you got a refill pack. Easy to take off used component and put on new refill.
Natasha R.
I love the color. But every pencil I use it wears down quickly and always ends up snapping in half towards the end so then I just have to throw it away.
Taunja B.
The color and texture of this pencil are just right ! I do wish it would last longer !
Rory B.
It can be frustrating when you are lucky enough to appear much younger than you are but then your brows are barely apparent anymore and not only does this take away from your eyes, the window to the soul, but also makes us look older and more "spare." This product really helps and it feels like I am not doing anything bad to my skin as so many other products have felt in the past. And on top of that, this is a slow steady return to complete brows!
Mary Jean P.
I love love this product but the set of 2 really doesn't last very long. Please make them 3 or 4 per pack, Thanks!
Jennifer S.
This is my most favorite brow pencil...ever! Perfect neutral tone and glides on so nicely...does not leave my brows after a full day of wear!
Rafaele V.
Nice set! It was a great value to get a full size pencil and a refillable duo. Great deal and an awesome product.
Gina H.
The 2-pack refill is convenient and eco friendly. The shipping was fast too. Ashy Daybreak matches by brows perfectly for summer when I have blonde highlights in my brunette hair. I also use Chocolate Decedance and Cinnamon Cashmere and I have the pomade in all three colors too. Plume products make my brows look great!
cerissa a.
Great pencil! My only complaint is is it runs out very quickly compared to other brands that would normally last 4X longer.
Elizabeth E.
Love this eyebrow pencil. So natural looking and so easy to apply.
Shasta G.
The absolute best eye brow pencil I've ever used!!! Best color for me! Ashy Daybreak is exactly my eyebrow color. It usually takes me forever to put on and eyebrow pencil but this one is so easy to apply and just glad John so perfectly.
Lanna C.
I love Plume products, this one is a nice way to fill in one spot. ❤️
Grace B.
Chestnut Decadence is my perfect match! I love the formulation and how it applies so smoothly. I am actually seeing hair growth too! Love it!
Priscilla R.
Love this brow pencil! I tried the pencil first and loved it so much that I ordered refills and brow pomade immediately. It’s super easy to use, glides on and looks perfect all day. I also like using the darker shade pencil to line the bottom part of my brows and fill in with pomade.
Jeanne B.
So far, I have purchased the brow pomade (love!) and the brow pencil (also love). Both products easy to use, and are yielding brow improvements. Now that I wear a mask whenever out of the apartment, at least my brows are expressive. Very much appreciate the clean ingredients in these products
Maneesha B.
This is THE best brow pencil I've tried and I've honestly tried them all (Anastasia, Bobbi Brown, Benefit, NYX, Zuzuluxe, Alima Pure...). The tip is so fine and the perfect consistency to build and fill in your brows in the most natural and flattering way possible. Not only that, but this truly does help with re-growing brow hairs. I had a bald spot in my brows at the end of last year that has completely grown back in, thanks to this amazing pencil! I love how eco friendly it is with the refills - super easy to change out. Recommending this to everyone!
